Case Results

Appellate Win: Baker v. Lowe

Appellate Win graphic for Baker v. Lowe, Louisiana First Circuit Court of Appeal, October 2, 2026
The Louisiana First Circuit Court of Appeal vacated a Family Court judgment that awarded visitation of a child to a non-parent, holding that the lack of adequate notice violated our client’s procedural due process rights.

On October 2, 2026, the Louisiana First Circuit Court of Appeal issued its decision in Baker v. Lowe, vacating a judgment rendered by the Family Court for East Baton Rouge Parish that had awarded visitation of a child to a non-parent.

EKF Family Law represented Ms. Lowe on appeal and raised several issues, including res judicata and the denial of her constitutional right to procedural due process.

An Earlier Dismissal, and a New Filing

An earlier proceeding in the 20th Judicial District Court ended with a judgment sustaining Ms. Lowe’s Exception of No Right of Action and dismissing Mr. Baker’s custody claims with prejudice. That judgment was not appealed. Less than two weeks later, Mr. Baker filed a new custody proceeding in the Family Court.

Res Judicata

Ms. Lowe argued that the earlier judgment in the 20th JDC barred the subsequent proceeding in the Family Court under the doctrine of res judicata. Although the First Circuit could not decide the exception because the necessary evidence from the earlier proceeding had not been introduced in the Family Court, it expressly recognized Ms. Lowe’s right to re-urge the Exception of Res Judicata on remand. Notably, in a footnote, the Court expressed “grave concern regarding the appearance of forum and/or judge shopping.”

The Decision Turned on Due Process

The ultimate disposition of the appeal, however, turned on due process.

Ms. Lowe had been given notice of a hearing involving an emergency custody request. At that hearing, the Family Court instead proceeded to adjudicate Mr. Baker’s custody claim under La. C.C. art. 133, even though that claim had not been set for trial. She argued that the lack of adequate notice violated her procedural due process rights.

“Adequate notice is one of the most elementary requirements of procedural due process.”

Louisiana First Circuit Court of Appeal, Baker v. Lowe

The First Circuit agreed. Recognizing that “adequate notice is one of the most elementary requirements of procedural due process,” the Court found that Ms. Lowe did not receive adequate notice that the Article 133 custody claim would be tried that day and, thus, did not have a meaningful opportunity to prepare for trial. The Court expressly held that the lack of proper notice violated Ms. Lowe’s procedural due process rights. The Court therefore vacated the judgment in its entirety and remanded the matter for further proceedings.

I am proud to have obtained this result for my client and to have successfully protected those rights on appeal.

Elizabeth K. Fox
Attorney, EKF Family Law

Case at a Glance

  • Case: Baker v. Lowe, No. 2026-CU-0593
  • Court: Louisiana First Circuit Court of Appeal
  • Decided: October 2, 2026
  • Appealed from: Family Court for East Baton Rouge Parish
  • Issues raised: Res judicata; procedural due process
  • Result: Judgment vacated; remanded for further proceedings

Facing a Custody or Visitation Dispute?

Talk with EKF Family Law about your options. Call (225) 465-7138 or email beth@ekffamilylaw.com.

Tags :
Child Custody | Family Law
Share This Post :